A good pizza brings people together. A great neighborhood pizza place keeps them coming back.
That’s been our story since 2005.
At Nicolo’s, we’re more than a restaurant. We’re a gathering place. A spot where families celebrate birthdays, friends reconnect after a long week, and neighbors become regulars.
In 2025, we were honored to be named Lakewood’s Best Food & Beverage—and while we’re proud of the recognition, what means the most to us is earning a place in our community’s traditions, celebrations, and everyday moments.
Sure, we’re known for our Chicago tavern-style pizza. Thin, crispy, square-cut—the way it ought to be. But what we’re really proud of is creating a place where everyone feels at home. From fresh salads and hearty pasta dishes to gluten-free, vegetarian, and dairy-free options, there’s a seat at the table for everybody.
So bring the family. Meet up with friends. Stay a little longer than you planned.
The pizza’s good. The company is even better.
